Posts

COURTROOM DRAMA 3: THE PAPER CHASE (1973)

Image
"This movie analysis contains spoilers"\ This blog is not owned by a professional movie reviewer. The Paper Chase,  an English film   directed by  James Bridges  -in  1973. Story by  John Jay Osborn Jr. My initial thought on this movie after reading the synopsis was that this is not a courtroom drama, but just a plain drama that revolves around a hardworking law student, who struggles between his studies and relationship. I had second thoughts on watching this film, as I was expecting more of hardcore like the previous film, 12 Angry men, or killing a mocking bird. Then I thought why not.  I was correct of course, this story was plain drama. We still can get the juice of it.  The lead character, James.T.Hart ( Timothy Bottoms ) a first-year student join a study group to share outlines of their course. A group consisting of six, each chooses a subject, works on the outline (notes) and shares with the rest of the group for the final exam. However, t...

வழக்கறிஞர் மதியழகனுடன் ஒர் உரையாடல்

கடந்த இரண்டாம் திகதி மார்ச் 2022, நானும் என் சக தோழி பவித்திராவும் வழக்கறிஞர் திரு மதியழகன் அவர்களை ஈப்போ, பேராக்கில் அவரது அலுவலகத்தில் கலந்து பேசிய உரையாடலை கீழே எழுதியுள்ளேன். இது ஒரு நேர்காணல் அல்ல. இங்கே, எங்களுக்காக நேரம் ஒதுக்கிய வழக்கறிஞருக்கும் இந்தச் சந்திப்பைத் தடங்கலின்றி ஏற்படுத்தி தந்த திருமதி அனித்தாவுக்கும் தகுந்த நன்றிகளைத் தெரிவிக்கும் வாய்ப்பிது. வழக்கறிஞர் மதியழகன் பற்றிய சிறு முன்னுரை; இவர் 2008 தொடங்கி 2015 வரை நயணம் பத்திரிக்கைக்கு எழுதி வருகிறார். இவரின் தனிச்சிறப்பு இவரின் எழுத்து நவீன இலக்கியத்தில் சேருவதாகும். அதாவது மக்களை நோக்கி எழுதக் கூடிய எழுத்து. இவரது சாமானிய வார்த்தைகளும், அவ்வப்போது வரும் கேளிக்கைகளும் மக்களை அதிக ஈர்க்கச்செய்யும். தனது சொந்த அனுபவங்களையும் வழக்குகளையும் எழுதி வரும் இவர், சமூதாயத்தின் அடிப்படை பிரச்சனைகளான நிலம், கல்வி, குடும்ப சிக்கல்கள், வணிகம் போன்ற துறைகளில் நாம் அறிந்திருக்கவே முடியாத பொக்கிஷங்களை எழுதி தள்ளுகிறார். படிப்பது நமது விருப்பம். அவர் அலுவலகத்தில் எங்களை வரவேற்று, நாங்கள் மூன்றாம் வருட சட்டக் கல்லூரி மாணவிகள், ஞாயிறு ...

LEGAL MOVIE 2 : 12 ANGRY MEN (1957)

Image
  "This movie analysis contain spoilers"\ This blog is not owned by a professional movie reviewer 12 Angry Men, a English film   directed by  Reginal Rose -in  1957. 12 juries  The story evolves around twelve juries with their perspectives, ideas, opinions and backgrounds to decide whether a minor Spanish boy from the slum is innocent in a murder trial. Each jury has their own characteristics, in fact they are all grown men. The most important jury is jury number #8. The story reveals the name, as Davis in the end. The taste of the movie is that, the effort of jury #8 being creative and logic to think and persuade others to stand by the justice.   Personally, I could understand the story well, of course certain scenes are deep, has to be read from other sources for better understanding. My favorite is jury #9. He is the only reason to flicker the flame of justice. Which means that, when juty #8 was struggling alone to say his thoughts, this old man her...

LEGAL MOVIE 1 : TO KILL A MOCKING BIRD

Image
 'This movie analysis has spoilers' As a legal enthusiast, I reminded myself to read and watch the classics before I can comment or critic in any of the current legal situations. For a start, I watched this famous movie [have not read the book yet] and decided to write down my reflection after watching it based on two forms; First, reflecting on legal basis. Second, reflecting overall in life. [Socio-Politic-Economy] I would like to divide this movie reflection into two.  Overall Reflection  This movie was based on Harper Lee's 1960 novel 'To Kill a Mocking Bird. Some backstory about the author is that, his father was a lawyer and he has defended two negroes on murdering a white shopkeeper.    The movie starts with Scott (Jean Louis Finch) a girl and daughter of Mr Finch (The lawyer) and her brother Jem living in the hot Maycomb, Alabama. The story is narrated by grown Scott as a voiceover. They hear about a man named Boo, who eats rabbits and cockroaches, ugly ...

OVERSIMPLIFIED CASE REVIEW: SURAINI KEMPE & ORS v. KERAJAAN MALAYSIA & ORS

Image
  CASE REVIEW ON CONSTITUTIONAL LAW SURAINI KEMPE & ORS v. KERAJAAN MALAYSIA & ORS HIGH COURT MALAYA, KUALA LUMPUR AKHTAR TAHIR J [ORIGINATING SUMMONS NO: WA-24NCVC-2356-12-2020] 27 SEPTEMBER 2021 [2021] CLJ JT(12) In Physics; Dispersion of Light by Prism In Legal Terms; Prismatic Interpretive Approach BACKGROUND FACTS  The President of the Association of Family Support & Welfare Selangor & Kuala Lumpur (Family Frontiers) is the first plaintiff, followed by mothers who are Malaysian citizens are second to the seventh plaintiff. The defendants consisted of the Government of Malaysia, the Minister of Home Affairs and the Director-General of the National Registration Department.  The case is about the plaintiff seeking a declaration on the impugned law regarding children born out of the Federation, to mothers who are Malaysian citizens, to be conferred citizenship by operation of law. Registration Department.  The said impugned law refers to art. 14...

OVERSIMPLIFIED CASE REVIEW: KETHEESWARAN KANAGARATNAM & ANOR v. PP [2021] 9 CLJ

CASE REVIEW ON CONSTITUTIONAL LAW. KETHEESWARAN KANAGARATNAM & ANOR v. PP [2021] 9 CLJ    HIGH COURT MALAYA, KLANG AZMI ABDULLAH J [NOTICE OF MOTION NO: BL-44-6-09-2020] 3 JUNE 2021   FACTS The applicants are Anmuni Maria, Yani Tri Anda and Fransisaka [Migrants]. Applicants are charged under s. 12 of Anti-Trafficking In Persons And Anti-Smuggling Of Migrants Act 2007. Offence of trafficking in persons s.12. Any person, who traffics in persons not being a child, for the purpose of exploitation, commits an offence and shall, on conviction, be punished with imprisonment for a term not exceeding fifteen years, and shall also be liable to fine. The prosecution delivered on the applicants as part of the evidence for the prosecution pursuant to s.51A Criminal Procedure Code Act 593. Delivery of certain documents 51a. (1) The prosecution shall before the commencement of the trial deliver to the accused the following documents: (c) a written statement of facts favourable to th...

PART 2: The separability principle in International Commercial Arbitration

B . ISSUE OF SEPARABILITY PRINCIPLE Article 18.2(a)&(b) AA 2005 (ACT 646) It is analogous to;  Section 7 Arbitration Act 1996 UK Article 16.1 Arbitration Act 1996 New Zealand Generally remodelled or is a restatement after the parent provision  Article 16 of the UNCITRAL Model Law Again from his book, I learned the PRINCIPLE OF SEPARABILITY that; Separability is the an arbitration clause considered as an separate agreement, detached from the main contract, therefore treated as an agreement independent of other terms of the contract. If the arbitration clause lacks autonomy, then there is no reason why Arbitral Tribunal should follow rest of the contract.  If the arbitration clause is autonomous, it has a life on its own. Therefore, it has to be treated as an agreement and will not be affected by possible nullity of the contract to which it belongs.  The arbitration clause survives the demise of the main contract then constitutes the necessary agreement of th...